You are right. I don't know how the ST's PGM-FI system works. But knowing how Jens Lyck has misled owners of other bikes which do negate the change with long term fuel trim, I'd want to know more before I "invested" in one for the ST. He disputes the people who have data from a wide band O2 sensor in the tailpipe showing that the change from his device is negated over time. His adherents still believe him and repeat his "logic" to people who have data to the contrary. I gave the AF-XIED as an example of a system that would work and keep working. The fact that it is unavailable for the ST does not make the BoosterPlug any better. I had a BoosterPlug on one of my bikes. I took it off but wouldn't sell it because it isn't worth anything. Maybe it works on the ST. I don't know - and you don't know either. But I do know that it won't be flowing prose from the "inventor" that convinces me.You said yourself you don't know the ST's system. The AF-XIED isn't available for the ST. Doesn't matter how good it is.
I believe that your statement that "The ECU wouldn't know the difference." is wrong. There is an O2 sensor in the tailpipe that will sense that the mixture is above the target A/F ratio and report it to the ECU. Your statement that "It wouldn't try to correct the fuel trim because there's no problem," assumes that the ECU would read a rich setting from the O2 sensor and then do nothing about it. Makes you wonder why it bothers to sense it, doesn't it? "it just thinks it's cold out." assumes more cognitive thought than the device is capable of.
Still admitting that I don't know the specifics of the ST EFI system, every closed loop EFI system that I have experience with uses the O2 sensor data as the final arbiter. There was a system from Dobeck that dummies up the O2 sensor data input to make the ECU think all is good and that the vehicle is still in warm-up mode, so it forces the ECU to stay in open loop mode and run the map. In open loop you can do anything you want.
Here is an interesting read from the world of Harley tuning...
https://www.drdyno.com/AIM_2010-09.html
Last edited: